Sunday, June 21, 2015

And now for something completely different: The Hegelian Dialectic

Trend Model signal summary
Trend Model signal: Risk-off
Trading model: Bearish

The Trend Model is an asset allocation model which applies trend following principles based on the inputs of global stock and commodity price. In essence, it seeks to answer the question, "Is the trend in the global economy expansion (bullish) or contraction (bearish)?"

My inner trader uses the trading model component of the Trend Model seeks to answer the question, "Is the trend getting better (bullish) or worse (bearish)?" The history of actual out-of-sample (not backtested) signals of the trading model are shown by the arrows in the chart below. In addition, I have a trading account which uses the signals of the Trend Model. The last report card of that account can be found here.

Update schedule: I generally update Trend Model readings on my blog on weekends and tweet any changes during the week at @humblestudent.


Hegelian Dialectic: Bull and bear debate
Regular readers know that I have been cautious on the US equity market for several months. Instead of re-hashing the same points over and over again, I thought that I would try something different this week. I will re-examine the bull and bear case for stocks in the framework of the Hegelian Dialectic of "thesis, antithesis and synthesis", otherwise known as "thinking outside the box".



Thesis: The bull case for stocks
New information has come to light recently that bolsters the bull case for equities:
  • Improving fundamentals
  • Sentiment readings are becoming bearish, which is contrarian bullish
  • Price strength in selected sectors, such as the all-time high achieved by the NASDAQ and Russell 2000, as an indicating of better price momentum
  • The high likelihood of a relief rally from a resolution of the Greek crisis (see Two ways to play Greece)
Let's go through each of those points, one at a time.


Better fundamentals
In the last few weeks, high frequency economic data has had a tendency to beat expectations, rather than disappoint as they've done for much of 2015. Rhe Citigroup Economic Surprise Index, shown below, is turning up, indicating an improving economic outlook. The Atlanta Fed GDPNow estimate of 2Q GDP growth has surged to 2.0% from a low of 0.7% in mid-May.


John Butters of Factset reported that consensus forward EPS estimates are growing in line with the better economic outlook. As the chart below shows, the change in forward EPS has been highly correlated with the direction of stock prices.



Sentiment getting too bearish?
In addition, sentiment models are getting more bearish. There was a lot of buzz generated early last week when the BoAML Fund Manager Survey (FMS) revealed that institutional managers had taken out a lot of tail-risk insurance, probably because of fears relating to  Greek tail-risk (more on that below).


The latest AAII survey also showed bullish sentiment to be very low on a historical basis, though Bespoke did point out that bearish sentiment also ticked up during the week as neutral sentiment retreated.


The latest II survey data also showed the bull-bear spread to have fallen to a new low for 2015:


NAAIM exposure has fallen to a 2015 low, which is also contrarian bullish.


The CNN Money Fear and Greed Index is also at depressed levels indicating rising bearishness.


Overall, these sentiment readings are suggestive of a crowded short and the formation of the proverbial wall of worry.


Technical strength + impending rally = ?
All these readings would be understandable if stock prices had taken a tumble, but that's hardly the case. The SPX fell about 3% on an intraday peak to trough basis but recovered late last week. In addition, several leading indices, such as the NASDAQ Composite and the Russell 2000, made all-time-highs.

In addition, I wrote last week that eurozone stocks and, in particular, Greek equities were no longer responsive to bad news from the Greek crisis, which indicated that they were poised for a relief rally. As the chart below of the Euro STOXX 50 indicates, eurozone stocks had been falling since April, but their uptrend from last September remains intact. 


The combination of the technical condition and skeptical psychology of the market leads me to believe that European stocks are likely to stage a significant relief rally once the Greek crisis is resolved - and it appears that a final resolution is highly likely next week. Given the high degree of correlation between US and European markets, a Greek inspired relief rally is likely to push US stocks higher as well.


Antithesis: The bear case
I have been writing about the bear case for so many weeks I am starting to sound like a broken record. The best summary can be found at my previous post Why I am bearish (and what would change my mind).

To make a long story short, the intermediate term bear case rests on a series of technical conditions that amount to more or less the same thing. Call you what you want, excessive complacency, deteriorating price momentum, uptrend violations - they all amount to the same thing. The monthly chart below illustrates my point (note that this is a monthly price chart and therefore daily squiggles don't matter very much). 

A 100% accuracy model in calling bear phases

The chart above has a 100% accuracy in calling bear phases in the last 20 years (N=5). Further analysis based on DJIA data going back to 1900 also came to the same conclusion. Whenever the MACD histogram (bottom panel) turns negative, the market is either in a bear phase (shown by the 12m rate of change in the top panel), or is about to enter into a bear phase. We saw MACD turn briefly negative in January 2015, tick back to positive in February, followed by relapse into negative and deteriorating MACD readings in starting in March 2015.

The intermediate term bearish argument is also supported by deteriorating breadth and other internals. This chart from IndexIndicators showed the % of SPX stocks above their 50 dma have been steadily declining. On Thursday, when the SPX rallied about its 50 day moving average on Thursday, the percentage of stocks in the SPX above its 50 dma was barely above 50% at a 53.8% reading. Taken together, that`s not a picture of strong breadth.


At the end of the week, much of the technical conditions that prevailed for much of 2015 was unchanged. The market remains in a tight trading range, with the RSI(14) indicator (second panel) staying highly range-bound, having refused to get either overbought or oversold all year. The shorter term RSI(5) indicator (top panel) reversed off an overbought reading on Friday, however, which is bearish on a 2-3 day time frame basis.


Intermediate term technical conditions continued to deteriorate. The equal to float weighted SPX ratio (green line, third panel) has been falling, indicating a negative breadth divergence. In addition, the relative price performance of HY bonds to equivalent duration Treasuries (bottom panel) has been rolling over and creates concerns about the quality of global risk appetite. 

There has also been a lot of recent discussion about weakness in the DJ Transports as a non-confirmation of the new highs in the DJ Industrials, which is a Dow Theory concern. Dana Lyons showed that not only are the Transports weak, the DJ Utilities are weak. Such conditions have tended to resolve themselves bearishly in the past.



Global risk appetite, which is what the Trend Model is measuring, is also a concern for stock prices. The UK FTSE 100 (not shown) is now under both its 50 and 200 dma. In addition, the Shanghai Composite has now fallen over 10% on a peak-to-trough basis and under its 50 dma, which puts it into correction territory. The chart below shows not only the Shanghai Composite, but the indices of Greater China, or China's major trading partners (except for Japan, which has its own issues). All of the regional bourses are struggling technically and several (Taiwan and Singapore) have violated their 200 dma, which is used to delineate bull and bear markets.


The technical difficulty of the stock markets of China's major trading partners illustrate the point that China has become an increasingly important part of the global economy. A report from Business Insider shows how Chinese imports have exploded over the last few years.


The number of countries that count China as its top trading partner has been steadily rising and now number 43. A Chinese slowdown would therefore have a much greater impact on the global economy than at the time of the Lehman Crisis in 2008, when the count was only 12.


China is the biggest marginal consumer of many commodities and the global growth signals from commodity prices is disappointing. The chart below shows the price of industrial metals (top panel) and the CRB Index (second panel) and the USD Index (bottom panel). I have also shown the cyclically sensitive industrial metals in euros and Australian Dollars. The key takeaway here is commodity prices are weak, regardless of currency. In particular, the recent decline in commodities in the face of a falling USD, which tends to be inversely correlated to commodities, is a warning sign that of weakening global demand, especially from China.


In conclusion, the combination of weak price momentum, deteriorating breadth and poor global risk appetite are all intermediate term bearish signs for US equities.


Rising earnings? Not so fast!
I recognize that the improving economy and rising EPS estimates is likely to provide a tailwind for equity bulls. However, Jim Paulsen at Wells Capital Management has a dissenting viewpoint. Paulsen wrote in his June letter that he was worried about margin pressures cutting into earnings growth. He observed that US corporate margins appeared to have reached a plateau:


...and unemployment is falling, which creates wage pressure and therefore squeeze margins. Historically, corporate profits have struggled once the unemployment rate reached the current level of 5.5%.


Paulsen also raised concerns about the effects of Fed tightening on the profit cycle. In the past, stock prices have continued to rise when the Fed started tightening "because the profit cycle is usually still in the early stages of recovering from the previous recession", but not this time [emphasis added]:
Of the many unique aspects characterizing contemporary monetary policy, one which may prove very important for the stock market is “how long” the Fed has waited to begin the tightening process. Our concern is not that by waiting so long, the Fed is behind the curve (although that also is possible). Rather, by waiting too long to start the process, the Fed has allowed its traditional exit ramp (i.e., raising interest rates against strong gains in corporate profits) to expire. Consequently, the Fed is now about to begin the process of raising interest rates without its traditional buffer of recovering profitability.
Jim Paulsen is no permabear and his views add a fresh perspective on the macro outlook for equities. He has been increasingly cautious on the stock market and his views should be given due consideration.


Sentiment: What fear really looks like
I also want to address the issues raised by apparent bearish sentiment readings. The US equity market has not seen a 10% correction since 2011, so many investors and traders may not really remember what real fear looks like. So if we were to accept the premise that the stock market appears to be vulnerable intermediate term, a wimpy 3% pullback is unlikely to create the kinds of sentiment backdrop for a durable bottom.

Let's take a look at what real fear has looked like in the past. Here is a 10-year chart of the AAII Bear to Bull ratio (in black) and the Rydex bear fund+money market to bull fund cash flow ratio (in green). True, bearish sentiment readings have spiked, but they are only slightly in the bearish side of neutral and nowhere near the extreme bearish readings seen at past market bottoms (marked by vertical lines). The same comment could be made about the AAII data.
.


Here is a chart of the VIX-VXV ratio, which measures the term structure of the VIX Index. When the ratio is above 1, it indicates backwardation in the term structure and a high level of fear in the market. Current readings can only be characterized as neutral and nowhere near the extreme fear readings seen at past market bottoms.


The NAAIM exposure readings appear ominous, but in reality they can only be characterized as neutral and not at a bearish extreme. I have indicated with circles what real fear has looked like in the past. 


One last thing, if everyone is so bearish on stocks, why did Lipper report that investors pulled $5.2b out of taxable bond funds and pour $6.9b into equity funds, with a $4.5b lion's share going into US equities?


Greece: Faites vox jeux
The key to the bull-bear debate in the short-term rests with Greece and how that crisis gets resolved. After many, many so-called "deadlines", it is finally crunch time for Greece and the crisis will likely get resolved next week, one way or the other. An emergency summit has been called for Monday in which Athens will undoubtedly be given a take-it-or-leave-it ultimatum. There are three scenarios to consider:
  1. Someone blinks and there is a deal. Even if it's an incomplete kick-the-can-down-the-road solution, we can pretty much expect that the markets will stage a relief rally. 
  2. Greece defaults but stays in the euro. We can look the Cypriot episode as a template of what might happen next. When the Cypriot banking system unexpectedly melted down, the authorities were able to contain the damage to the eurozone financial system and equity market downside was limited. Stocks rallied soon afterwards.
  3. Greece defaults and leaves the euro. This is highly unlikely. The Europeans don't want to kick Greece out and the Syriza controlled Greek government does not appear to be operationally prepared to leave the euro (see this discussion about what's involved at Naked Capitalism). It took years of preparation to transition from national currencies to the euro and such a change can't be done overnight without causing total chaos. I don't find Grexit to be a credible threat for the immediate future.
As an aside, I have written before that the problems that Greece faces are intractable and the solutions advocated by each side only addresses part of the problem (see What would happen after a "Speech of Hope"?). I am not here to make moral judgments, but to ascertain what the likely trajectory of the European markets will be next week. Consider the alternatives. Option 1 is obvious, the markets rally. Option 3 is unlikely for the reasons I outlined, so let's explore what happens with the discussions leading up to option 2.

Yves Smith at Naked Capitalism provided a useful synopsis of how such a scenario might play out. It has been said that the euro was a flawed monetary union from the beginning and the strains might even lead to war. Indeed, we are seeing a form of war as the Europeans have very effectively weaponized the financial system. Smith highlighted analysis from David Zervos of Jeffries of how it might all play out over the next few days [emphasis and comments added]:
1. Greece misses its IMF payment on the 30th of June. This could be a trigger but it may not be. The IMF has 30 days to call Greece in arrears so technically Greek government guaranteed collateral, and hence the Greek banks, are still solvent after the 30th. However on the 20th of July the Greeks will surely default to the ECB without a deal. This is the official d day.

2. Upon default, the collateral at Greek banks cannot be posted any longer to the Euro system. The Greek banks then become insolvent and the ECB, through the newly created Single Resolution Mechanism (SRM), is obligated to resolve the Greek banks. [Cam: Klaus Regling of the European Stability Mechanism has stated that their loans are linked to the IMF and a default to the IMF is a default to ESM.]

3. So the ECB goes to Tsipras and tells him – we are immediately instituting capital controls [Cam: Actually the decision to impose capital controls is up to the member state and not the ECB, but that's only a minor detail] and we will begin resolution of your banks unless u sign the agreement and re-enter a program. Without a bailout program in place the Greek government, and banking system, are both insolvent. So Tsipras says – what do you mean resolve my banking system? And then Mario explains as follows. First we wipe out all equity and bond holders. And then, as in Cyprus, we bail in depositors. There are 130b in Greek deposits against 90b in ELA. And while those deposits are technically insured up to 100,000 euro, there is no pan European bank insurance yet in place. That only comes in 2016. Right now Greek deposits are only insured with a Greek deposit insurance fund that has about 3b in it. This Is hardly enough for the 130b in deposits. So we take the 130b against the 90b in ela. Any remaining deposits go to fund a bad bank that begins resolving all the NPLs. The good loans of course will go into a good bank which will be funded with German capital and most likely will have a German name. Of course depositors will get 2 to 3 euro cents on the dollar for their existing balances from the 3bio in the insurance fund. So you have that going for you!

4. Tsipras hyperventilates and quickly reaches for a bottle of ouzo.

5. Then it’s basically time for the gallows. He either signs a document cutting pensions, raising VAT and violating all his red lines. Or he takes the Greek people into bankruptcy and out of the euro. Either way he is a dead man. His own party destroys him if he does the former [Cam: and his wife leaves him]. And the 70 percent of Greek who want to stay in the euro destroy him if he does the latter. Of course there is one other choice for Tsipras. He could just resign and call for new elections. In that case maybe the banks stay closed and the ECB does not start the resolution process until the Greek people decide what they want. But in any event, it’s over for Tsipras in that case as well.

The German fiscal disciplinarians have won the battle. Tsipras dies under that bridge. The end!
A weaponized financial system indeed! These kinds of bare knuckled negotiating tactics are likely to push Tsipras into blinking, signing a deal and falling on his political sword. As the time of this writing, Bloomberg has reported that Tsipras has presented Merkel, Hollande and Juncker a last-minute proposal that crosses his own red lines on pension reform. We'll have to see how much ground Greece has given and if the provisions are satisfactory for the Eurogroup.

Supposing that Tsipras doesn't sign the deal and decides to default, we can consider the Cypriot experience of what might happen next. The chart below shows the price action of the Euro STOXX 50, the SPX (top panels) and the Athens General Index (bottom panel) during the Cypriot bail-in. The Greek banking system was highly exposed to Cyprus so it had a higher Cypriot beta, while US stocks were the least exposed so they barely reacted at all. European stocks were somewhere in between. Stock prices fell on the day that capital controls were announced (remember that it was surprise). They staged a two-day rally (weak for Greece, stronger for Europe), declined for a week afterwards to a bottom and then rose afterwards. The lack of reaction from the SPX was likely indicative of how far removed the Cypriot situation was from the US economy and financial system.


The bottom line: Expect a short-term rally, followed by a possible decline into an ultimate bottom. In any case, the downside is limited.


Synthesis: Long Europe, short US
Based on this analysis, I continue to believe that the intermediate term direction for US stock prices is down. US equities moved into a mild overbought condition on Thursday and, if recent history of the narrowly range-bound market were to repeat itself, we are likely to see further declines early in the week. On the other hand, a bearish beta exposes a simple short position to the risk of a Greek driven rally. Quantitative models suggests that the beta of the SPX to Greek news is relatively low. This chart of the relative performance of Greek stocks compared to eurozone stocks indicate that the rolling 20-day correlation of Greek relative performance to the SPX is only 0.30.


This chart shows that DAX volatility has spiked while VIX has remained flat (via Jeroen Blokland), which is another disconnect.


However, these results appear highly counter-intuitive. Even with the best quantitative tools, I cannot predict how the US markets are likely to react to a Greek rally.

As a solution, my inner trader has decided to do something completely different. He has entered into a pair trade, where he is long eurozone and short US stocks to express his convictions and control risk (see my tweet last Friday) .The chart below shows the long FEZ-short SPY pair. European stocks in USD have been in a trading range against US stocks for most of 2015 and the pair is now at the bottom of the range. The RSI(5) indicator (top panel) shows that it has flashed a buy signal by bouncing off an oversold condition. Should this pair move back to the top of the range, the upside potential would be about 4.5%. If the Greek market beta of SPX is lower than eurozone stocks, which is a reasonable assumption, the upside potential could be a lot higher.



On the other hand, my inner investor remains cautious as he remains focused on the intermediate term downside risks in US equities.


Disclosure: Long SPXU, EURL

Wednesday, June 17, 2015

Two ways to play Greece

Are you getting tired of the Greek news? I know I am. The market seems to be tired of Greece too.

This is a chart of the Greek ETF (GREK). Despite all of the dire news that's been coming in in the past few weeks, GREK hadn't fallen very much and has failed to make new lows. This kind of price action suggests that most of the bad news is already in the market.


Here is the Euro STOXX 50, which peaked in April and has been in a downtrend since May. The index is now just above a support zone that could serve as a near-term floor. Does this mean that most of the Greek bad news is already priced into the market?



An examination of the market internals of other major European averages on IndexIndicators also suggests that eurozone stock markets are also washed out. This chart of the average 14-day RSI of DAX stocks are nearing oversold levels where it has staged decent rallies in the past.


Here is the same chart for the CAC 40. The conclusion is the same.


These readings are highly suggestive of a "sell the rumor, buy the news" strategy, where Mr. Market has already capitulated and fear is rampant.


Conflicting messages
How can we square these technical conditions with the Bloomberg report that Street strategists haven't capitulated and they remain bullish on eurozone equities (emphasis added)?
Greece isn’t budging, and neither are Europe’s stock strategists.

Clashes between officials in the Mediterranean nation and its creditors are wreaking havoc on markets, yet none of the 15 forecasters tracked by Bloomberg lowered their year-end estimate for European indexes. All of them see gains. UBS Group AG even raised its projection this month, citing better-than-expected earnings growth and a turn in the economy.

With analysts projecting three straight years of earnings growth surpassing 10 percent and European Central Bank stimulus in force, equity forecasters view Greece jitters as temporary. A Bank of America Corp. survey showed the region is still favored among stock investors. Citigroup Inc., the most bullish firm, sees the Stoxx Europe 600 Index jumping 17 percent through the end of the year.
The latest BoAML Fund Manager Survey indicates that institutional fund managers remain heavily overweight eurozone equities, with a net 46% of manager overweight the region to a 1.3 standard deviation level above their historical average exposure.


The FMS also shows that institutional managers are not positioned for the worst case scenario, with 43% expecting a last-minute deal and 42% expecting a Greek default:


The technical conditions and the survey data are highly contradictory and make no sense. Is the Street bullish or bearish on Europe?

All this has happened in the face of today`s Bank of Greece dire warning of floods, plagues and locusts what might happen should Greece fail to reach an agreement (emphasis added):
Failure to reach an agreement would, on the contrary, mark the beginning of a painful course that would lead initially to a Greek default and ultimately to the country's exit from the euro area and – most likely – from the European Union. A manageable debt crisis, as the one that we are currently addressing with the help of our partners, would snowball into an uncontrollable crisis, with great risks for the banking system and financial stability. An exit from the euro would only compound the already adverse environment, as the ensuing acute exchange rate crisis would send inflation soaring.

All this would imply deep recession, a dramatic decline in income levels, an exponential rise in unemployment and a collapse of all that the Greek economy has achieved over the years of its EU, and especially its euro area, membership. From its position as a core member of Europe, Greece would see itself relegated to the rank of a poor country in the European South.
After tabling that report, the governor of the Bank of Greece Yannis Stournaras was attacked by the House Speaker for "uninhibited intervention". In the meantime, anti-austerity Syriza forces has begun a demonstration to show that even if the Tsipras-led government were to compromise and there was a deal, they would have to bring out the tanks to enforce its terms.

This picture is worth a thousand words:





Traders vs. investors
Here is my interpretation. Trader and investors should behave differently in the current circumstances.

For traders: The fast money crowd has been selling Greece (and eurozone stocks) in anticipation of a negative resolution to the negotiations. Judging from the technical condition of the markets, they are nearing a crowded short condition and a significant relief rally is likely when any resolution of the issues, whether positive or negative, hits the tape. The most likely negative trigger would be the ECB either refusing to support the Greek banking system any further through ELA, or requiring higher haircuts on Greek paper pledged as ELA collateral.

For investors: The ultimate measure of the value of stock prices are its earnings and the discount rate to those earnings. Investors therefore have to make a decision on the likely effects of any Greek resolution have on those factors. A deal, even if it's a temporary solution, will obviously be bullish for European equities.

On the other hand, suppose that Greece were to default, but uncertainty remains as to whether it would stay in the euro. I have highlighted in the past that a Greek default would hit the budgets of other eurozone governments badly, with Italy being the most exposed (see Bears wake up, but they're not out of the woods). Under those circumstances, the contagion effects would be very real as peripheral yield spreads would likely widen and risk premiums rise, which negatively affects the discount rate on earnings. As well, the viability of Greece in the eurozone and the EU itself would also shake the very foundation of the European Union.

One of the benefits of the introduction of the euro was a greater economy of scale. Not only did the euro simplify the cost of doing business in the eurozone, which raised the earnings growth rate, it created an economy of scale in the corporate bond market. A Dutch company could finance a cross-border acquisition of an Italian company, or vice versa, more cheaply because of the better depth of the euro-denominated corporate bond market, compared to a single currency one like the Dutch Guilder. Much of those benefits could come into question.

Institutions have large equity holdings with positions that they can only trade in and out of in months, not days and minutes like fast-money traders. The BoAML FMS indicates that they are overweight the eurozone and they will likely be re-evaluating their eurozone equity exposure if Greece were to go over a cliff. In the case of a relief rally in the face of a Greek default or Grexit, investors should take the opportunity of any relief rally to lighten their positions.

Bottom line: Traders should buy the news of any resolution, investors should wait for the news and then decide on what to do next.

Tuesday, June 16, 2015

Return of the bond market vigilantes?

As we await the FOMC statement and the Janet Yellen press conference after the FOMC meeting, I thought that I would highlight the results of the latest BoAML Fund Manager Survey (FMS). A review of the FMS indicates that institutional managers are relatively bearish on the bond market outlook.

First, it isn't surprising that they expect higher short rates:

The expectation of a 3Q (read: September) rate hike is a fairly consensus call at 54% of the manager sample:

However, inflationary expectations are rising, which would put more upward pressure on yields at the long end and likely lead to a steepening yield curve.

When asked what the biggest tail-risk facing the market was, the Fed behind the curve was the second choice behind a geopolitical crisis.

When I put it all together, fund managers are expecting higher rates, higher inflation but they're afraid that the Fed might be behind the curve. This seems to be a recipe for the return of the bond market vigilantes (see my recent post Global risk off = More downside for stocks).

The chart below of the UST 10-year yield indicates that it has moved up through a downtrend (blue line) and may be in the middle of an up channel (dotted green lines).


When the FOMC releases its statement and Fed chair Yellen speaks in the press conference, I will be closely watching how the shape of the yield curve changes to see if my hypothesis about the bond market vigilantes is correct.


Sunday, June 14, 2015

Global risk-off = More downside for stocks

Trend Model signal summary
Trend Model signal: Risk-off
Trading model: Bearish

The Trend Model is an asset allocation model which applies trend following principles based on the inputs of global stock and commodity price. In essence, it seeks to answer the question, "Is the trend in the global economy expansion (bullish) or contraction (bearish)?"

My inner trader uses the trading model component of the Trend Model seeks to answer the question, "Is the trend getting better (bullish) or worse (bearish)?" The history of actual out-of-sample (not backtested) signals of the trading model are shown by the arrows in the chart below. In addition, I have a trading account which uses the signals of the Trend Model. The last report card of that account can be found here.

Update schedule: I generally update Trend Model readings on my blog on weekends and tweet any changes during the week at @humblestudent.


A global risk-off episode
I've been saying for several weeks that US equities were ready to fall on an intermediate term basis and it seems that the decline is beginning. I had struggled to find a fundamental bearish trigger, but as stock prices began to retreat, two concerns were weighing on the market:
  • Rising interest rates, particularly at the long end of the yield curve; and
  • Greece.
What we saw last week was a global risk-off mood gripping the markets. Let`s take a quick tour around the world and you will see my point.

In the US, stock prices were dragged down by a declining risk appetite in the credit markets. The chart below shows the relative performance of high-yield and emerging market bonds slump against their equivalent-duration Treasuries (top panel). Equity breadth continued to deteriorate, as the equal-weighted SPX continued to underperform against the float-weighted SPX (green line, middle panel). As well, the percentage of stocks above the 200 day moving average fell to a low as it broke a "support" level, possibly indicating that the bears had taken control of the tape with negative price momentum (bottom panel). The SPX ended the week below its 50 dma, which is another sign of failing price momentum.


The negative breadth momentum has been very broadly based. In fact, it prompted the Leuthold Group to put out a research note highlighting the fact that both the DJ Transports and DJ Utilities have undergone "death crosses", where the 50 dma have fallen below the 200 dma. If history is any guide, subsequent returns are expected to be poor:

Across the Pacific in Asia, the stock indices of Greater China countries, or China's major trading partners in the region, continued to show weakness. With the exception of the Shanghai Composite, the stock indices of every other major Asian market were below their 50 dma. Despite Beijing`s best efforts at economic stimulus (see Gavyn Davies' China gets serious about reflation), the markets appear to be discounting slowing growth coming from China.


I am also seeing similar signals from the commodity markets. China remains the biggest marginal consumer of many commodities but commodities remain under pressure, despite the pullback in the USD, which is inversely correlated to commodity prices. The top two panels of the chart below shows the prices of industrial metals (top panel) and the CRB Index (second panel). To filter out the effects of the USD, I have shown the cyclically sensitive industrial metal prices in euros (third panel) and Australian Dollars (fourth panel). Stated simply, commodities are showing weakness, regardless of the underlying currency.


Stock prices in Europe are under pressure as well. The chart below compares the SPX, the UK FTSE 100, the Euro STOXX 50 and the Athens General Index. All major European indices have fallen below their 50 dma, indicating that negative momentum has taken hold. Paradoxically, Greek stocks appear to be bottoming out and they seem to have staged a rally out of a downtrend (more on Greece below).


From a global risk appetite and an inter-market analytical perspective, these are worrisome signs in that they paint a picture of a broad-based risk-off trend. Such an environment can`t be good for stock prices.


The return of the bond market vigilantes
One of the more bearish signs for risky assets is the rising correlation between stock and bond prices. At the end of April, bond prices began to fall and bond yields backed up. Stocks also staged a minor retreat, but recovered. And now, bond yields are rising again across the globe and stock prices are weakening as well.

The apparent cause of the fright in the bond market has been rising inflationary expectations, both in Europe and the US. After several years of low to zero interest rates, the market got into a crowded long by chasing yield. Ambrose Evans-Pritchard writes that the dramatic unwind of this trade caused a crash in the eurozone bond market:
The bond crash has been an accident waiting to happen for months. Money supply aggregates have been surging all this year in Europe and the US, setting a trap for a small army of hedge funds and 'prop desks' trying to squeeze a few last drops out of a spent deflation trade. "We we're too dogmatic," confessed one bond trader at RBS.

Data collected by Gabriel Stein at Oxford Economics shows that 'narrow' M1 money in the eurozone has been growing at a rate of 16.2pc (annualized) over the last six months. You do not have to be monetarist expert to see the glaring anomaly.

Broader M3 money has been rising at an 8.4pc rate on the same measure, a pace not seen since 2008.

Economic historians will one day ask how it was possible for €2 trillion of eurozone bonds - a third of the government bond market - to have been trading at negative yields in the early spring of 2015 even as the reflation hammer was already coming down with crushing force.

"It was the greater fool theory. They always thought there would be some other sucker to buy at an even higher price. Now we are returning to sanity," said Mr Stein.
Across the Atlantic, US growth is also rising and so are inflationary expectations:
M3 growth in the US has been running at an 8pc rate this year, roughly in line with post-war averages. The growth scare earlier this year has subsided, as was to be expected from the monetary data.

The economy has weathered the strong dollar shock and seems to have shaken off a four-month mystery malaise. It created 280,000 jobs in May. Bank of America's GDP 'tracker' is running at a 2.9pc rate this quarter.
Everyone got into crowded long and the reversal, when it came, was very unpleasant:
Funds thought they were on to a one-way bet as the European Central Bank launched quantitative easing, buying €60bn of eurozone bonds each month at a time when fiscal retrenchment was causing fresh supply to dry up. They expected Bunds to vanish from the market altogether as Berlin increases its budget surplus to €18bn this year and retires debt.

Instead they have discovered that the reflationary lift from QE overwhelms the 'scarcity effect' on bonds. Contrary to mythology - and a lot of muddled statements by central bankers who ought to know better - QE does not achieve its results by driving down yields, at least not if conducted properly and if assets are purchased from outside the banking system. It works through money creation. This in turn lifts yields.
Despite the soothing rhetoric from the Federal Reserve about being cautious and moving slowly on monetary policy, bond market vigilantes may very well tighten for the Fed by pushing up bond yields at the longer end of the yield curve.

Recent high frequency economic releases have been steadily improving and should lead to rising interest rates. The rising growth trend is exemplified by the Atlanta Fed`s GDPNow has now spiked to 1.9%, up from 0.6% about a month ago. These signs of renewed growth should solidify a September interest rate liftoff - watch the FOMC statement next week.


I am watching to see if the commentary to shift from a fear of rising interest rates to a fear that the Fed is behind the curve on raising rates, which would send the bond market into further conniptions. As an example, Jim Paulsen of Wells Capital Management more or less said the same thing as he openly worried about an inflation shock in the US (via Bloomberg):
For the first time in 15 years, demand in the world’s largest economy is outpacing supply. The result could be an inflation shock that roils financial markets, according to Wells Capital Management Inc.

“Regardless of its overall speed, an economic recovery is at risk of overheating whenever demand grows faster than supply,” Jim Paulsen, the Minneapolis-based firm’s chief investment strategist, told clients in a report this week. “Since most investors are not anticipating any serious overheating evidence, we are concerned a potential inflation scare, could produce a significant change in financial-markets pricing.”

By combining labor supply and the weakest productivity for any expansion since World War II, Paulsen reckons U.S. supply -- or an economy’s capacity to produce goods and services -- has grown just 2 percent since the recession ended six years ago. That’s so slow that it’s even being surpassed by otherwise disappointing demand, something investors have failed to appreciate, he said.

A volatility divergence
Notwithstanding the fact that stock and bond markets are inter-connected, here is the key reason why I believe that a bond market sell-off is likely to negatively affect equities. This chart below shows the history of realized stock and bond market volatility going back to 1980. Historically, bond market vol has been lower than stock market vol. Most recently, however, bond market volatility has spiked but stock volatility has remained stable. How long before equity vol catches up to bond vol?

This chart from Thomson-Reuters tells a similar story. Not only has fixed income volatility risen, but currency (FX) volatility has spiked as well, while equity volatility remains tame.


The option market has already reacted to this anomaly by buying a lot of VIX calls compared to VIX puts in anticipation of a rise in stock market volatility. In the short-term, Bloomberg reported that the spike in VIX call buying may be traders positioning for the FOMC meeting next week:
“This is people getting ahead of the Fed, buying equity volatility because it has been low relative to rates and FX volatility,” said Pravit Chintawongvanich, a New York-based derivatives strategist at Macro Risk Advisors. “Equities have been in a very tight range lately and people feel like something has got to give.”

Longer term, however, the disparity in fixed income (and FX) volatility compared to equity vol sticks out like a sore thumb. As the VIX Index tends to be inversely correlated to stock prices, a spike in fixed income (or FX) volatility that spreads would be highly negative to equity markets.

These cross-asset concerns have led the Societe Generale`s strategy team to make a call to de-risk portfolios (via Bloomberg):
Correlations have significantly increased between asset classes and it therefore becomes difficult to naturally protect portfolios through asset class diversification: for the first time in a long time we recommend raising the cash allocation (+4 point to 11%) to better manage portfolio risk...

We reduce our equity and bond allocation by 2 points (to respectively 45% and 36%). To enhance risk diversification, we upgrade our weightings in alternative investments (now 8%), including commodities (up 3 points).


Risk off, indeed!


The market`s big fat Greek bet
I wrote earlier that the behavior of Greek stocks suggested that a crowded short had developed in Greece. The inability of the Athens General Index to fall in response to bad news indicated that much of the negative news was already in the market. So that should be bullish, right?

The answer to that question is a "yes, but..." for a couple of reasons. First of all, just because the market does not or will not respond to bad news doesn't mean that bad things, such as a Greek default, can't happen. More importantly, negative events like a default will also affect the rest of Europe - and the market doesn't seem to be prepared for such an eventuality. In fact, a crowded long seems to have formed in European equities, which may be problematical should events spiral out of control next week and too many investors try to rush for the exits at the same time.

The latest BoAML Fund Manager Survey indicates that global managers are overweight eurozone equities to a crowded long reading. Up until recently, the general consensus among institutional managers was that Greece would come to a "kick the can down the road" agreement with its creditors and put off the day of reckoning yet one more time.


As well, Ryan Detrick showed that American individual investors have been selling out of US stocks and piling into international stocks through both mutual funds and ETFs (annotations in red are mine):




While international equity flows do not necessarily mean that they have gone into Europe, I would expect that European equities have received more than its fair share of these fund flows. A negative resolution of the Greek crisis has the potential to create a sudden shock to these over-long holders of eurozone equities and cause a panicked rush for the exits.


Greece on the brink, again!
As I write these words, Greece is on the brink yet one more time. I have written about what I believe to be the key issues in the Greek crisis so I won't repeat them here (see What behavioral finance tell us about the Greek negotiations and What happens after a "Speech of Hope"?). Now consider the latest developments in the Greek crisis:

There have been many stories about the drop-dead deadlines for the talks between Greece and the EU-IMF. June 30 has been mentioned a number of times, but that seemed to be unrealistic as any deal would require approval by other eurozone parliaments before June 30. A more realistic drop-dead deadline seems to be the Eurogroup meeting of finance ministers next Thursday on June 18.

The most shocking development of the negotiation process occurred last on Thursday, June 11. The Greeks had been in discussions with the EU and talks appeared to be proceeding smoothly when the IMF dropped the bomb that it was withdrawing its negotiating team, citing insufficient progress. ECB officials left as well, leaving only the EU leg of the troika in talks. The departure of the IMF team from the negotiating table was a stunner and dramatically dropped the odds of concluding a deal. The Guardian reported that the EU is now preparing for a Greek default, which had been an unthinkable option until now, at least officially (emphasis added):
Greece has less than a week to strike a deal with its eurozone creditors to avoid defaulting on its massive debts and perhaps being kicked out of the single currency area, with German leaders and top European Union officials now conceding that default is the likeliest outcome...

Merkel was said to have resigned herself to a Greek default, and at a meeting on Thursday night in Bratislava, eurocrats preparing for the Luxembourg talks included the default scenario in their discussions for the first time.

Until Friday EU executives have refused to countenance the prospect of default and the issue has not been discussed at any official level.
The Germans had been preparing for such an eventuality:
According to German media reports on Friday, Berlin has also begun contingency planning for Greek default scenarios. The plans were said to include the introduction of capital controls in Greece, closure of the banks, and the government’s issuing of IOUs to finance its public sector.

There is no exit plan for any country to leave the euro, but economists have suggested that such IOUs could then become a pseudo-currency, but they would circulate only within Greece. They would be impossible to use for international trade.

“The chancellor now knows that there is not enough time left,” one of Merkel’s aides told German mass-circulation newspaper Bild-Zeitung.
Part of the problem is the IMF has different priorities than the EU. IMF chief economist Olivier Blanchard laid it out in a blog post. Greece has to commit to a credible restructuring program that crosses Syriza`s red lines of pension and wage reductions (emphasis added):
On the one hand, the Greek government has to offer truly credible measures to reach the lower target budget surplus, and it has to show its commitment to the more limited set of reforms. We believe that even the lower new target cannot be credibly achieved without a comprehensive reform of the VAT – involving a widening of its base – and a further adjustment of pensions. Why insist on pensions? Pensions and wages account for about 75% of primary spending; the other 25% have already been cut to the bone. Pension expenditures account for over 16% of GDP, and transfers from the budget to the pension system are close to 10% of GDP. We believe a reduction of pension expenditures of 1% of GDP (out of 16%) is needed, and that it can be done while protecting the poorest pensioners. We are open to alternative ways for designing both the VAT and the pension reforms, but these alternatives have to add up and deliver the required fiscal adjustment.
The EU has to agree to writing off part of the debt, which is very difficult for eurozone governments to swallow. Given the political constraints that the face value of the debt cannot be written down, Blanchard indicated that debt restructuring the debt by writing down its NPV is the answer (e.g. if I owe you $1 million but can't pay, I could pay it off at $1 a year for the next million years):
On the other hand, the European creditors would have to agree to significant additional financing, and to debt relief sufficient to maintain debt sustainability.We believe that, under the existing proposal, debt relief can be achieved through a long rescheduling of debt payments at low interest rates. Any further decrease in the primary surplus target, now or later, would probably require, however, haircuts.
So what happens if Greece were to default? The WSJ reported that ECB Governing Council Jens Weidmann stated that while the effects of a Greek default are largely firewalled, they would not be totally benign (emphasis added):
Mr. Weidmann said at an event in London that “there is a strong determination to help Greece improve its public administration, remove barriers to growth and put public finances on a sustainable path.” Furthermore, “taxpayers from other euro-area countries have provided substantial funds to support the unavoidable adjustment processes.”

“But time is running out, and the risk of insolvency is increasing by the day,” he said.

He said the contagion effects of such a scenario “are certainly better contained than they were in the past, though they should not be underestimated.”

"Margin clerk market" risks rising
Now imagine if Greece were to be unable to reach an agreement next week and decides to default on its payments to the IMF. As I write these words, weekend talks ended with no agreement and there are rumblings of an Greek default plan based on the Icelandic model. I outlined the negative consequences to Europe last week, as Italy would be most exposed to a Greek default (see Bears wake up, but they're not out of the woods). Peripheral bond yields would blow out against bunds and chaos would ensue. Add the crowded long in European equities on top of that and the elements of a market panic would be in place.

In conclusion, the equities are vulnerable to a pullback but there are a number of event risks that could turn any orderly pullback into a panic. A jittery bond market and a Greek default are both possible negative catalysts that could spark a rout should too many investors try to head for the exits at the same time. I can easily envisage a "margin clerk market", where the combination of margin calls and haywire risk estimates from VaR models force the liquidation of positions, any position, as all asset prices fall and asset correlations converge to 1.


Waiting for the buying opportunity
Should a disorderly sell-off materialize in the days or weeks to come, I would urge investors not to panic. So what if the "animal spirits" have taken over? The US economy remains robust and there are no signs of a recession, which is the ultimate bull market killer, on the horizon. I agree with Bill McBride of Calculated Risk in his assessment that the odds of a recession in 2015 and 2016 is low.

The latest update from John Butters of Factset indicates that forward EPS growth remains strong, which should be supportive of higher equity prices should markets panic and fall for technical reasons.


This likely correction is most likely a mid-cycle pause as the SPX hasn't seen a 10% correction since 2011. This chart from BoAML shows the returns of US stocks before, during and after Fed tightening cycles. Historically, the biggest downside has been seen in the time leading up to the first rate hike, which is the period we are in now. Equities have performed well over the tightening cycle, largely because the economy and earnings growth are accelerating.


Barring signs of an imminent recession, my inner investor is inwardly rubbing his hands with glee should a market correction occur as it would present an opportunity to buy stocks at a discount.


The week ahead
In summary, the intermediate term condition of the US equity market is bearish. Market internals and momentum metrics are all rolling over. That does not mean, however, that stocks can't rally next week. Notwithstanding aforementioned "margin clerk market" risks, this chart of net 5-day high-lows from IndexIndicators show that the market is neither overbought or oversold on a short-term basis, though the momentum is negative.


Longer term breadth and momentum indicators also tell the same story. The readings are neutral but the momentum is negative.


In addition, a review of this chart of the SPX shows that it reached an oversold condition on RSI(5), which is a good swing trading indicator with a 2-3 day time horizon, and bounced last week. However, RSI(14) remains range-bound and hasn't seen an overbought or oversold reading this year. Option based sentiment models, such as the VIX/VXV ratio that measures the VIX term structure, is showing benign conditions and no signs of fear.


Based on these near-term assessments of the technical condition of the equity market, even if we were to follow the 2015 narrative of a wimpy-bull-wimpy-bear range-bound market, the short-term momentum for stocks is down next week. Combined with the bearish intermediate term conditions, I can only conclude the path of least resistance for the SPX is down. Initial support can be found at the rising (dotted) trendline at 2085, with further support at 2070 and then at 2040. Should the market rally and decisively break through resistance at its 50 dma, a test of the all-time highs is possible.

My inner investor remains cautious but not panicked. My inner trader is short the market as the risk-reward is tilted to the downside.


Disclosure: Long SPXU